Pain Skills LibraryA parish-quiet directory

Home / Listings / Problem-solving therapy (PST) for persistent pain

CBT SkillsClinician-led

Problem-solving therapy (PST) for persistent pain

A clinician-led, worksheet-driven CBT-family skill for practical barriers around living with pain. Stronger for depression than as a pain treatment. A one-sitting 5-step worksheet is weaker and is not full PST.

Problem-solving therapy is a stepwise clinic method. You treat a hard day as a practical problem you can work, not as proof you are helpless. Then you define the barrier, list options, decide, try one, and review. The “problem” is a solvable obstacle around living with pain (getting groceries, a work accommodation, a hard conversation), not “make the pain vanish.”

It is not “just stay positive.” It is not values work and not ACT. It is not activity pacing. It is not the whole CBT-for-pain course (problem-solving is one ingredient of that package). It is not manifestation. Pain is treated as real. Some pain is not a problem you solve.

How to ask for it

  1. Ask primary care, a pain clinic, or (if eligible) VA mental health for Problem-Solving Therapy or Problem-Solving Treatment in Primary Care (PST-PC). A useful check: “Do you use a D’Zurilla/Nezu or Hegel PST-PC protocol: orientation, define, alternatives, decide, do, review?” If they only offer thought records, values exercises, or pacing quotas, that is a different listing.
  2. A real course is time-limited and worksheet-driven, and it works one defined problem at a time. IMPACT-style PST-PC was 6 to 8 sessions; many VA/Nezu courses are about 10 to 12 weekly sessions. If the offer is “manifest a pain-free life,” crystals, or “just stay positive,” it is not PST.
  3. Use VA Moving Forward only as a map, not as treatment. The free course and worksheet walk the planful steps. They do not replace a clinician, a medical workup, or CBT for pain if that is what is needed.
  4. If the live problem is fear of movement, boom-bust activity, or values-stuckness, use those neighbor listings instead of forcing PST to do their job.
  5. If you cannot keep yourself safe, call 988. Do not use a worksheet as crisis care. If function, fear, and pain thoughts still dominate after a few honest PST cycles, ask for CBT for pain, not more solo worksheets.

A 5-step try that is not full therapy

Pick a practical obstacle, not “solve the pain.” Example: “I cannot get this week’s groceries without a two-day crash.”

  1. Orientation. This is a solvable task problem, not proof you have failed.
  2. Define. Facts only. Name the goal and the obstacles.
  3. Generate. List at least three options. Do not judge them yet.
  4. Decide. Weigh short- and long-term pros and cons. Write a small action plan.
  5. Implement and review. Try it. If it failed, check the definition, the options, the trade-offs, or the follow-through, then adjust.

This one sitting is not 6 to 12 session PST and not values-based action.

If the honest definition is “this still hurts and I cannot fix the body today,” lament psalms and breath prayer remain the right neighbor listings. Do not baptize a positive stance as guaranteed healing.

This page is educational information only. It is not medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Talk with a licensed clinician before changing your care, especially if pain is new, worsening, unexplained, or you have other health conditions. Do not stop medications or ignore warning symptoms based on what you read here. Pain is real. Nothing here means it is all in your head.

This is not a medical workup. A beginner worksheet is not 6 to 12 session PST. Do not use a worksheet for suicidality or crisis; call 988 (Veterans: 988, then 1). Do not aim the steps at “make the pain vanish.” Do not merge this with activity pacing or with ACT. VA Moving Forward is a self-help map and does not replace a clinician. Some pain is not a problem you solve. IMPACT pain gains cannot be billed as “PST cured arthritis pain.”

Who it is for

People living with persistent pain who have a practical barrier to work (groceries, a work ask, a crash after a good day) and can meet with a clinician trained in PST or PST-PC. Not for “solve the pain,” not for crisis, and not a substitute for CBT for pain.

Notes on evidence

Do not treat this as a unique, large PST-for-pain literature. Support is stronger for depression and distress (VA/DoD suggests PST among psychotherapies for uncomplicated major depression; better-quality depression trials show small effects). Cochrane 2020 did not analyse standalone PST; problem-solving is one ingredient of typical CBT-for-pain packages. Lin 2003 (IMPACT) found less pain and interference in older adults with arthritis and depression, but the intervention mixed antidepressants, care management, and optional PST-PC versus usual care, so it cannot isolate PST. McAndrew 2022 (telephone PST versus health education in Gulf War illness) found no primary disability difference at 12 weeks and no difference on exploratory pain. That is the best qualifier against “PST treats pain.”

Related listings